Hit a deer ... now what to replace?

[justin4fun]

So I was cruising down the highway at about 70 mph when out jumps Bambi's mom ... smack! right off the front of the drivers side. Considering the speed I was going, not too bad ... about $2100 worth of damage including the factory grille guard, fog light, and headlight.

I got my money from the insurance company and trying to decide what to do about the grille guard... replace with another OEM or go with another.

I'm thinking I'd like a stainless steel one rather than black, but not sure how the aftermarket ones would hold up vs the factory one.

I kind of like the Manik heavyduty
http://www.suvxccessory.com/mnks-453050sp.html

but the price of this is tempting too
http://cgi.ebay.com/Grille-Grill-Brush-Guard-SS-HUMMER-H3-SUV-OEM_W0QQitemZ300002263227QQihZ020QQcategoryZ33645Q QcmdZViewItem

Any opinions?